Double Standard

The guy drinks too much.  Smokes dope on the job and is ‘under the influence’ way more than not.  He’s a bit less than attractive, too.  His work is excellent despite that, and he could drywall a scarecrow to look like a supermodel.  Admittedly, he looks a bit anti-social and, being in such a trade, he is always dusty, unkempt, down at the heels and looks like something the cat wouldn’t even drag in.  I met him a few years ago.  He was a good guy to me and Sally.  And we liked him.

After a shift at a job he was on a few days ago, he left late in the morning.  The reason for that is that he starts very early or sometimes works through the night.  Drywalling work is not compatible with other trades work. Contractors and other subtrades prefer the drywallers to be unseen, unheard and yet do perfect work – somehow magically.  That usually means working weird hours.  Drywallers try to work around the other trades.

His job at this time was in an expensive penthouse in Downtown.  After work, he walked to his car, stayed in it for a few extra minutes, maybe making a call and then, driving less than perfectly, made his way out of the lot.  I know this because his actions were caught on the security tape and also because the security tape was soon being reviewed.

An outraged woman told security that her laptop had been stolen from her car.  She had arrived at the building early and left before noon, shortly after the departure of the drywaller. The cameras showed only him walking in the area during this time.  They did not show that he broke into her car and they did not show him carrying a laptop.  But she concluded that he was the thief.  She called the chair of the strata building, they called the police and they also called the general contractor who had let the drywall contract to the fellow being accused. The two women demanded that the drywaller return the computer and they demanded the contractor fire the guy and that the general also do extra credential checking to ensure that his other tradespeople were not criminals.

The general contractor apologized to the drywaller but said he had no choice but to fire him a few days before Christmas because that was the alleged victim’s and the strata council’s chair’s demand.  The contractor also offered to replace the missing laptop, even though he did not believe his subtrade worker had taken it.  It is worth noting that the owner of the penthouse – the one who hired the contractor – was not involved. The person making the accusation was simply a woman claiming to have been keeping an early appointment in the building. She was supported in that contention by the chair with whom the meeting had occurred.

The drywaller denied the allegation but had no choice but to stop work.  He would lose a large portion of his December income since he had set aside the time to do this job and had no other contract to continue with.  Given his proclivities, he might be excused if he had simply given up on December and was planning on spending even more time less conscious.

After all the running around and firing and the setting of hair-on-fire had played out the woman called the building manager. She called to inform him that she had erred.  She had left her computer at home.

A new drywalling firm had already been hired.  The contractor had spent the day running one way and then the other. The previous drywaller had his reputation impugned.  The building manager was embarrassed and offered the drywaller $100 from his own pocket as an apology. The chair of the strata board was not heard from.  She ducked away. Neither has the woman who made the accusation apologized or made good any type of compensation.

Now imagine this story playing out a bit differently.  In this version it is the drywaller who’s computer is missing from the front seat of his car. In this fantasy version it is the smartly dressed business woman who is caught on the security tape walking to her car and getting into it. In this version the drywaller views the video with the building manager and concludes the woman is a thief.  The police are called. The outraged drywaller insists that this woman’s employer be called and that she be fired on the strength of his allegation. And that her co-workers and boss are informed of this misdeed and their backgrounds are also re-checked.

Do you see that ever happening? Of course not.  So why is it happening here?  Is it the clothes?  Is it the type of work they do?  Could it be a gender bias?  Is it perceived social status?

And, given the example set of ‘trying to do the right thing’ by the general contractor and the building manager, why, if the two women learn of their error are they not falling all over themselves trying to fix it?

Can anyone explain that to me?

6 thoughts on “Double Standard

  1. As Scotty would say. “Skip it.”
    Entirely off subject, but did you notice MSP premiums just went up 6.9 %? Even after you prepaid 6 months? The increase is Retroactive! I wish my maladies were.


      • The other 10% is sloth, ignorance, expensive duplication, bid rigging, etc.
        Let accountants run everything.
        At least it would save us from seeing Christy Clark on the nightly “news” spewing forth more of her nonsensical inanities.
        I can dream cant I?


  2. I used to manage office buildings downtown for over 20 years. EVERY time a theft occured the janitors were immediately blamed.
    The majority of janitors were a) immigrants from a 3rd world country where a theft accusation is very very bad news.
    b) Very hard workers
    c) Honest as the day was long.
    99% of the thefts were the young(mid 20’s), usually male but not always, underpaid support staff. I did catch one elderly judge on a covert security camera causing repeat vandalism in elevators to the tune of 10’s of thousands of dollars( he quietly resigned when confronted). Security guards involved in theft rings. Females of all ages. But it was usually young, white, men making little more than minimum wage.
    The one and only time a janitor took something was a case of stupidity on the part of the tenant.
    “I had a brand new laptop and now its GONE! The damn janitors MUST have taken it!”.
    “Where was the laptop”, I asked
    “THERE! RIGHT THERE!” said the tenant angrily while pointing AT THE GARBAGE CAN…..
    “You put your brand new laptop in the garbage?”, I asked incredulously.
    “No! It was ON TOP! I didnt have enough room on my desk to download files from my old laptop so I put it there and ran cables to it. When I was done I put it back in its case and went home. I want it BACK and I want that janitor FIRED!”


    ” So……your new laptop was sitting on the garbage can. Unplugged. No cables attached……..
    ” Well, I’m pretty you’re right. The janitor threw out your new laptop because they thought it was garbage because it was on top of the GARBAGE CAN….”
    I let that sink in to the fevered brain of the lawyer that was about to explode. then I added, ” You complained last week that the janitors were’nt emptying your garbage can on a nightly basis and last night YOU left your new laptop ontop of the same garbage can….What did you expect to happen? Its gone. The garbage trucks are here at 7am to dump the bin”

    I’d trust a janitor before I’d trust a lawyer.


  3. It’s a type of profiling. It’s systemic as recently recognized by the RCMP commissioner with his statement that some police officers are racist. Canada has issues with the ‘other.’ All my life I’ve hear comments about this group or that group who fail to measure up. RG


  4. Well my wife would not stand for the strata president acting like that. I would know immediately because it is me.

    I know you too Dave, I hope the person wasn’t too damaged. There’s a 4 letter word that starts with a c… worst word I know, ‘cept the reporter did have enough class to recant and explain.

    So, what do we learn here? Nothing is written in stone just because it is written on paper I think. Or, perhaps nothing is written in stone.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.